What’s good for the goose ain’t good for the gander! On cock-eyed counterfactuals and the R&D performance effects of Indian firms

Alex Coad
By: Alex Coad, CENTRUM Católica Graduate Business School, Santiago de Surco, Lima, Peru, acoad@pucp.edu.pe

profilepic

 

Nanditha Mathew, Sant’Anna School of Advanced Studies, Italy, n.mathew@santannapisa.it

 

Emanuele_Pugliese

 

 

Emanuele Pugliese, Institute of Complex Systems, CNR, Rome and Department of Economics, University of Bath, emanuele.pugliese@gmail.com

 

 

For Citation: SITE4Society Brief No.10-2018
Related to SDG Goals and Indian National Programmes: #SDG8 (Decent Work and Economic Growth) #SDG9 (Industry, Innovation and Infrastructure) #IIGP (India Innovation Growth Programme) #AIM (Atal Innovation Mission)
Economics sub-disciplines: Industrial organization, Development economics, Economics of innovation.
SITE focus: Innovation
Country focus: India
Based on: Alex Coad, Nanditha Mathew and Emanuele Pugliese, “What’s good for the goose ain’t good for the gander:cock-eyed counterfactuals and the performance effects of R&D” LEM Working Paper, No. 2017/21.

Context: In developed and emerging countries, government policies target firms in the manufacturing sector to encourage them to engage in innovation. Even though there is a consensus at a macro level that innovation is a main driver of economic growth, at a micro level, the relation between innovation and growth is not clear. Previous empirical studies at the micro-firm level have revealed confounding results concerning this relationship, and thus, there is no consensus on whether or not R&D undertaking improves firm performance. Such lack of clarity questions the policies that assume that innovation is beneficial for all firms that engage in innovation. Moreover, most of the studies deal with firms in developed countries and it is not clear whether such results hold for emerging country firms.  Hence, in this work, we investigate the innovation-firm performance relationship of Indian manufacturing firms, keeping in mind the findings of previous studies that have highlighted the firm characteristics that distinguish ‘innovative’ from ‘non-innovative’ firms. Finally, with respect to Indian manufacturing firms, we explore the counterfactual story: what would have been the performance effects of firms that did not invest in R&D, if they actually did and vice-versa.

Manufacturing_line (1)
Research Questions: Which kinds of firms spend on research and development? Do all firms benefit from research and development spending?

Motivation for Research Questions:  It is indeed crucial to disentangle and understand clearly the relationship between innovation and performance at a micro level, given the interest in the topic from both firm managers and policy makers.  It is noteworthy that several studies investigating the relationship between R&D and firm performance in terms of growth, productivity or profitability have shown conflicting results including – a positive relationship (Hall, 1987; Singh, 1994; Del Monte and Papagni, 2003), no relationship (Geroski et al., 1997; Bottazzi et al., 2001; Stam and Wennberg, 2009) or a negative relationship (Brouwer et al., 1993; Freel and Robson, 2004).
Furthermore, studies have identified that innovators have some characteristics that are distinctly different from non-innovators (Hall et al., 2010; Audretsch et al.,2014), but ironically, much of the studies have not properly empirically accounted for them and this could be the reason for contradicting results observed by previous studies.
Manufacturing_Line
Indeed, the effectiveness of technological investments such as R&D investment is likely to depend on innovative capabilities that are correlated with both the R&D decision and the expected performance benefits. Firms without these capabilities would be ill-prepared to invest in R&D and would probably not benefit from R&D if they did. The irony of the standard econometric approach, however, is that performance benefits from R&D are evaluated by assuming homogeneous effects for innovators and non-innovators. In this work, we demonstrate and emphasize that a non-R&D investor need not be a good counterfactual for an R&D investor.

Methodology:  The Prowess database, provided by the CMIE (Centre For Monitoring Indian Economy Pvt. Ltd.) was used. Firm performance was measured using two variables: sales growth of the firm and firm profitability. The R&D expenditure of firms was taken as their investment in innovation.
The innovation performance linkage was evaluated by performing an OLS and Fixed Effect estimation. This gave us inconsistent results: the R&D dummy did not have any significant effect on firm growth, and furthermore had significant negative effects on relative profitability.
However, as we pointed out before, innovators and non-innovators could be different from one to the other, and considering them the same could have been the reason for the poor results.
We empirically investigated this using  econometric techniques suited for dummy dependent variable, like Linear Probability model (Logit), Probit and a random effects Probit estimation and confirmed this to be the case.
Textile1_11004f
Hence, we faced two issues: first the issue of selection, i.e, the firms that invest in R&D are different from those that didn’t, and second, the issue of censored data, i.e R&D spending can only be a positive value. To tackle these issues, we applied the endogenous switching regression which allows to compute the counter-factuals in order to calculate the effect of investing in R&D for firms that actually did R&D and the effects of R&D investment for those that did not. In other words, using this method we could confirm the benefits of R&D investment for the two firm clusters separately. The results we obtain with this method are clear and sharp.

 Main findings: 

  1. Firms that invest in R&D and those that don’t differ significantly in terms of several observed firm characteristics. Firms performing R&D are bigger, younger, exporters, with high capital investments and financial leverage (i.e. total borrowings over total assets).unnamed (1)
  2. This leads to a self-selection bias, i.e. when a firm is bigger, exporting and has a lot of capital equipment – it probably has to engage in R&D.
  3. Once controlled for the selection bias, it is possible to make a causal interpretation of the results. Our results indicate that both firms that invest in R&D and those that do not are making a rational decision.
  4. Indian firms investing in R&D would have had less growth and less relative profitability if they had not invested in R&D and firms that did not invest in R&D would not have had better performance if they had done so. This implies that even if policy makers observe performance benefits of innovative activity among innovative firms, nevertheless this should not be taken to imply that there might be any benefits from encouraging non-innovative firms to invest in R&D.
  5. Our approach and results provide a possible explanation for why there is no consensus in the existing literature on the performance benefits of innovative activity. This could have been either because of the nature of the information available on firms or because the studies did not distinguish between low and high R&D investors.
  6. Our study demonstrates that firms investing in R&D can be making a rational decision and that firms that are not investing in R&D can also be making a rational decision. This should remind econometricians that firms are not as irrational as we might sometimes think, and that their decisions are based on much more information than are included in standard econometric specifications.

 

Policy Relevance: 
In academic and policy debates, it is often assumed that for all firms, R&D spending is beneficial in all circumstances. But this is not true – what is good for the goose might not be good for the gander!
india-climbs-global-innovation-charts-for-second-year-in-a-row.jpgFor example, our study indicates that in the Indian manufacturing sector, R&D spending is good for firms, which are younger, exporters, with high capital investments and low financial leverage, while R&D spending might not yield much benefits for firms that have never done R&D before.  In short, R&D investment is not for everyone!

how-to-get-20-percent-roi-from-property-investment-1920x1037Hence, firms that do not do R&D could be having good reasons to do so and vice-versa. This would indicate that a homogeneous economy wide tax breaks on R&D might not be an optimal policy. Innovation policies should be sector and technology specific, and any incentive should be shaped considering the characteristics of the firms involved. This is important to maximize the effects of the incentives, to ensure that firms do not undertake R&D for mere tax benefits, without any innovation output.
Sources of images:

  1. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Manufacturing_line.jpg
  2. https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Manufacturing_Line.jpg
  3. http://www.fforce.in/impact-of-gst-on-manufacturing-industry/
  4. http://economictimes.indiatimes.com
  5. https://colordarcy.com/how-to-earn-20-return-on-your-property-investment/
  1. RandyDed

    deep web drug store deep web drug url

  2. MatthewSmeXy

    darknet market list darknet markets

  3. MichaelHow

    dark web markets dark website

  4. JosephMeamn

    deep web drug url dark web websites

  5. RobertCof

    Hey! Thanksgiving owing to you for too revealing us there this. Jasper Plumbing I have in the offing right away moved to a advanced shelter and definite to perfectly remake our contemporary dining room. Since any личность who comes to our parliament is surely plausible to stop this place. In design, I advance easy materials and colors of nature. I liaison the halcyon mean without slick accents. And the options from your article look justifiably inviting and stylish. Consequently, it remains to opt a style and bring it to life.

  6. ShanePak

    dark web search engines tor market

  7. DavidHam

    dark web link onion market

  8. RichardViorb

    darknet market lists darknet market lists

  9. CharlesExips
  10. Brandoncok

    dark web markets darkmarket url

  11. BrandenEmago

    darknet market links dark market list

  12. CharlesTHERN
  13. HillMog

    darknet links darknet site

  14. Michaelsenue
  15. CrisVer

    tor dark web tor market url

  16. SteveWax

    tor market url darkweb marketplace

  17. Rodneymax
  18. Carlvow
  19. PatrickBab

    dark market onion darknet markets

  20. Grantskets

  21. DavidZet
  22. EdgarMella

    tor market url dark website

  23. Zacharytuh
  24. DamonSoasp

    darknet sites dark markets

  25. Brianmub

    how to access dark web dark markets

  26. Michaelamics

    bitcoin dark web best darknet markets

  27. Jameserrom

    darknet seiten drug markets onion

  28. Hectorrulky
  29. DonaldAdali

    darknet markets darknet links

  30. RichardDaync
  31. WilliamInamb

    black internet dark internet

  32. JamesGlild

    tor markets tor market

  33. DannyEnsug

    dark market url dark web market links

  34. TimmyVAW

    dark web market links tor market

  35. Hellycalay

    deep web drug url darknet market lists

  36. JustinBum
  37. Ugovow
  38. Wendelldualf

  39. Randyteabe

    dark web search engines tor dark web

  40. SirMog

    blackweb official website dark website

  41. EdgarTib
  42. RobertNem

    dark web markets dark web markets

  43. Haroldeffob

    darkmarket deep web links

  44. GeraldCoola

    free dark web deep web drug store

  45. RobertDem

    darknet markets dark markets

  46. RonaldMus

    tor darknet dark web websites

  47. Ralphswilk

    tor marketplace dark web sites

  48. JackieGuelo

    tor markets 2022 darknet drug store

  49. WilliamCogma

    darknet site tor markets

  50. JasonKit

    darknet drugs darkweb marketplace

  51. TornItede

    deep web sites dark web market links

  52. FrankdiZ

    darknet search engine dark web link

  53. Kiavow
  54. Davidves

    deep web drug markets darknet seiten

  55. JuliannoM

    dark market url dark web markets

  56. ADWat

    deep web sites tor darknet

  57. Juliustum

    dark market 2022 tor markets links

  58. DavidGam
  59. Amyvow
  60. RandyDed

    darknet site darkmarket 2022

  61. JosephMeamn

    deep web sites darknet market links

  62. MatthewSmeXy

    deep dark web dark web access

  63. MichaelHow

    dark market link dark web site

  64. BrandenEmago
  65. DavidHam

    tor markets 2022 tor market links

  66. Brandoncok

    dark web markets darkmarket url

  67. CharlesExips

    dark web markets deep web drug markets

  68. RichardViorb

    tor marketplace darkmarket 2022

  69. CharlesTHERN

    dark market 2022 dark website

  70. MiclInork
  71. ShanePak

    blackweb official website dark web websites

  72. SteveWax

    deep web sites dark web sites

  73. Craigpef

    darknet site dark market url

  74. CrisVer

    dark web market links darkmarket

  75. Timothygor
  76. HillMog

    darkmarkets dark web link

  77. Grantskets

  78. PatrickBab

    tor markets 2022 dark web market

  79. MichaelBiams
  80. DavidZet

    blackweb official website darknet marketplace

  81. EdgarMella

    dark web market dark web search engines

  82. Zacharytuh

    dark website dark market list

  83. Corrydrent

    bitcoin dark web the dark internet

  84. Brianmub

    tor marketplace deep dark web

  85. Michaelamics

    blackweb official website darknet websites

  86. DonaldAdali

    dark web markets deep web drug url

  87. Jameserrom
  88. WilliamInamb

    deep web drug url darkmarket

  89. JamesGlild

    onion market darkmarket link

  90. RichardDaync

    dark web markets tor market

  91. DamonSoasp

    dark web websites darkmarkets

  92. DanielCet

    dark web drug marketplace darknet links

  93. Hectorrulky

    darknet marketplace darknet sites

  94. TimmyVAW

    dark market 2022 darkmarkets

  95. DannyEnsug

    dark websites tor market

  96. https://cipro4world.top

    Wһen I initially commented I clicked tһe “Notify me when new comments are added”
    checkbox and noԝ each time a commеnt is adԁed I how to gеt
    cheap cipro рrice (https://cipro4world.top) thrеe e-mails with thе same
    comment. Ιs there any way you can remove mе from that service?
    Appreciatе it!

  97. Wendelldualf

  98. Randyteabe

    darkmarket url darknet marketplace

  99. MarvinTam
  100. Teovow
  101. RobertNem

    onion market tor marketplace

  102. SirMog

    dark web market list dark web search engines

  103. MiclInork
  104. rocket league hitbox

    I know this if off topic but I’m looking into
    starting my own blog and was curious what all is needed to get set up?

    I’m assuming having a blog like yours would cost a pretty
    penny? I’m not very web smart so I’m not 100% positive.
    Any tips or advice would be greatly appreciated. Kudos

  105. HansGluby

    dark web link dark web link

  106. Haroldeffob

    deep web search dark web access

  107. JanZex

    deep web drug url tor marketplace

  108. RobertDem

    dark website dark internet

  109. JackieGuelo

    best darknet markets tor markets

  110. JasonKit

    dark internet deep web drug store

  111. Jimvow
  112. RonaldMus

    dark web search engine dark market list

  113. GeraldCoola

    dark market 2022 darkmarket list

  114. WilliamCogma

    darknet drug store dark web markets

  115. FrankdiZ

    free dark web deep web drug links

  116. ADWat

    darknet seiten dark web links

  117. Juliustum

    deep web drug store blackweb

  118. Brandoncok

    tor market tor market url

  119. JosephMeamn

    dark market 2022 darknet market

  120. RandyDed

    darkmarket list darknet websites

  121. CharlesExips

    darkweb marketplace darknet drugs

  122. BrandenEmago

    deep web drug store darknet search engine

  123. DavidHam
  124. MatthewSmeXy

    tor marketplace drug markets dark web

  125. SteveWax

    darkweb marketplace best darknet markets

  126. MichaelHow

    deep web drug store deep web sites

  127. JuliannoM

    darknet market lists the dark internet

  128. RichardViorb
  129. CharlesTHERN

    darkmarket list darknet site

  130. Davidves

    dark websites blackweb

  131. Jimvow
  132. CrisVer

    dark web market links darknet market lists

  133. ShanePak

    dark web search engines darknet drugs

  134. CharlesGag
  135. Craigpef

    drug markets dark web darkmarket 2022

  136. Grantskets

  137. Jackvow
  138. WilliamTom

    Are you looking for an example? check

  139. PatrickBab

    deep web sites dark web markets

  140. Corrydrent

    best darknet markets darknet search engine

  141. DavidZet

    darknet markets darknet markets

  142. Williambrido

    deep web links onion market

  143. Evavow
  144. Zacharytuh

    darknet seiten darknet sites

  145. EdgarMella

    deep web links darknet websites

  146. HillMog

    best darknet markets dark market onion

  147. Michaelamics

    deep web search blackweb

  148. Brianmub

    darknet market lists dark website

  149. JamesGlild

    dark web sites tor market

  150. WilliamInamb

    tor markets links dark market list

  151. RichardDaync

    dark web sites links tor market links

  152. Jameserrom

    darknet drug links dark market url

  153. DannyEnsug

    dark internet dark market onion

  154. Hectorrulky

    how to access dark web deep web links

  155. TimmyVAW

    tor market links darknet sites

  156. JamesStone

  157. Randyteabe

    dark market link tor market url

  158. DamonSoasp

    deep web drug links darknet sites

  159. Ralphswilk

    deep web links darkmarket list

  160. RobertNem

    dark market 2022 dark web search engines

  161. SirMog

    deep web links darknet links

  162. Yonvow
  163. JanZex

    dark web sites links darkmarket 2022

  164. Haroldeffob

    tor market url darknet drug market

  165. DavisNen
  166. RobertDem
  167. JasonKit
  168. JackieGuelo

    dark web links dark web sites

  169. RonaldMus

    drug markets onion how to get on dark web

  170. GeraldCoola

    darkmarket 2022 dark web search engines

  171. SteveWax

    dark markets 2022 darknet market list

  172. JosephMeamn

    darknet market list blackweb official website

  173. CharlesExips

    darkmarkets dark net

  174. Brandoncok

    tor markets 2022 dark web sites links

  175. Juliustum

    darkmarket list how to access dark web

  176. ADWat

    bitcoin dark web best darknet markets

  177. RandyDed

    darkmarket link darknet site

  178. FrankdiZ

    free dark web dark market link

  179. DavidHam

    deep web links darkweb marketplace

  180. WilliamCogma

    dark market 2022 tor dark web

  181. MatthewSmeXy

    deep web sites free dark web

  182. MichaelHow

    darknet seiten darknet drug market

  183. RichardViorb

    tor market dark web access

  184. CharlesTHERN

    dark web drug marketplace darknet site

  185. JuliannoM

    darknet market lists dark market onion

  186. CrisVer

    dark web markets dark market 2022

  187. JustinBum

    deep web sites darknet marketplace

  188. Corrydrent
  189. Grantskets

  190. ShanePak

    tor darknet dark market

  191. PatrickBab
  192. Davidves
  193. Craigpef

    best darknet markets deep web search

  194. Michaelamics

    dark market list dark internet

  195. DavidZet

    deep web drug store onion market

  196. Zacharytuh

    dark web markets onion market

  197. JamesGlild

    dark web sites bitcoin dark web

  198. EdgarMella

    dark market onion dark market

  199. Brianmub

    darkmarket url darkweb marketplace

  200. Randyteabe

    dark market 2022 dark web sites links

  201. WilliamInamb

    darkmarket url tor markets

  202. RichardDaync

    the dark internet darknet market

  203. Wendelldualf

  204. Jameserrom

    dark websites onion market

  205. DonaldAdali

    dark web site deep web links

  206. Ashvow
  207. MiclInork
  208. DannyEnsug

    darknet site deep web search

  209. TimmyVAW

    darknet markets blackweb

  210. Hectorrulky

    darkmarkets dark web websites

  211. HillMog

    how to get on dark web onion market

  212. HansGluby

    best darknet markets the dark internet

  213. Ashvow
  214. DamonSoasp

    dark markets darknet seiten

  215. Janevow
  216. RobertNem
  217. SirMog

    dark markets dark net

  218. TornItede

    darknet sites darknet market list

  219. Haroldeffob

    darknet links darknet drug links

  220. JasonKit

    dark websites deep web search

  221. DavidGam
  222. SteveWax

    darknet drug links dark web links

  223. RobertDem

    dark websites darknet market

  224. Janevow
  225. JackieGuelo

    deep web search darknet links

  226. JosephMeamn

    darknet search engine darknet websites

  227. RandyDed

    tor marketplace tor markets links

  228. ADWat

    dark web search engines darkweb marketplace

  229. CharlesExips

    tor marketplace drug markets dark web

  230. FrankdiZ
  231. Brandoncok

    dark web market links dark market 2022

  232. DavidGam
  233. Juliustum

    darkmarket 2022 darkweb marketplace

  234. RonaldMus

    darknet market tor market

  235. DavidHam

    dark web websites deep web sites

  236. GeraldCoola

    dark web search engines dark web links

  237. MatthewSmeXy

    dark web search engines dark web link

  238. zvgw61

    difference between levitra and cialis levitra max dose brand levitra

  239. MichaelHow

    darknet sites darknet sites

  240. DanielCet

    the dark internet deep web sites

  241. CharlesTHERN

    deep dark web dark web access

  242. RichardViorb

    dark web access dark web access

  243. HillMog

    tor markets links dark web search engine

  244. Kimvow
  245. Corrydrent
  246. Jimvow
  247. CrisVer

    dark web links darkweb marketplace

  248. Davidves

    drug markets dark web the dark internet

  249. Grantskets

  250. JuliannoM

    deep web drug markets blackweb

  251. PatrickBab

    darknet site dark market onion

  252. Georgemub
  253. JamesStone

  254. ShanePak

    deep web drug links darknet websites

  255. Michaelamics

    black internet deep web links

  256. DavidZet

    dark markets tor market url

  257. Markvow
  258. Zacharytuh

    dark web drug marketplace dark market 2022

  259. Ralphswilk
  260. RichardDaync

    deep web drug markets how to get on dark web

  261. JamesGlild

    darknet drug market dark market list

  262. Brianmub

    darknet drug links deep web drug links

  263. WilliamInamb
  264. EdgarMella

    dark web market blackweb

  265. Craigpef

    darknet websites dark website

  266. Jackvow
  267. Lisavow
  268. Jameserrom

    dark web links drug markets dark web

  269. DonaldAdali

    deep web search deep dark web

  270. TimmyVAW

    tor markets links dark internet

  271. DannyEnsug

    darkmarket url dark market onion

  272. Hectorrulky
  273. JanZex

    darknet drugs darknet marketplace

  274. EdgarTib
  275. DavisNen
  276. RobertNem

    dark web search engine darknet marketplace

  277. SirMog

    dark market dark market 2022

  278. DamonSoasp

    dark market onion tor darknet

  279. BrandenEmago

    dark web websites dark web link

  280. Ugovow
  281. Haroldeffob

    how to get on dark web dark web links

  282. JasonKit

    dark web market links dark markets 2022

  283. RobertDem

    dark markets 2022 dark web site

  284. Juliustum
  285. JackieGuelo

    dark market list darknet market

  286. CharlesExips

    dark web drug marketplace darknet drug market

  287. Brandoncok

    tor marketplace dark market

  288. JosephMeamn
  289. ADWat

    darknet market list blackweb

  290. RandyDed

    bitcoin dark web dark internet

  291. FrankdiZ

    darknet websites darkweb marketplace

  292. Yonvow
  293. EstebanFax
  294. JustinBum

    free dark web dark markets

  295. DavidHam

    how to access dark web tor darknet

  296. Judyvow
  297. RonaldMus

    tor marketplace free dark web

  298. MatthewSmeXy

    darknet websites tor market

  299. Corrydrent

    dark web links dark web market

  300. GeraldCoola

    darknet links darknet drug links

  301. CharlesTHERN

    dark web access drug markets onion

  302. MichaelHow

    darknet drug links free dark web

  303. CrisVer

    tor markets deep web drug url

  304. RichardViorb

    dark web drug marketplace dark web market

  305. Grantskets

  306. WilliamCogma

    how to get on dark web dark web access

  307. Georgemub
  308. Wendelldualf

  309. PatrickBab

    tor market url best darknet markets

  310. HansGluby

    deep web drug url dark website

  311. DavidZet

    tor dark web dark net

  312. Michaelamics

    darknet site dark web market

  313. JuliannoM

    dark website deep web search

  314. Zacharytuh

    darknet websites dark web links

  315. Davidves

    deep web search darkmarket

  316. RichardDaync

    tor dark web darkmarket 2022

  317. JamesGlild

    dark web websites darknet drug store

  318. WilliamInamb

    the dark internet tor markets links

  319. EdgarMella

    deep web drug markets dark web access

  320. ShanePak

    dark web markets darknet drugs

  321. Brianmub
  322. Jameserrom

    darkmarket 2022 darkmarket

  323. Craigpef

    dark website dark web link

  324. DonaldAdali

    darknet drug market how to get on dark web

  325. TimmyVAW

    drug markets onion dark market list

  326. DannyEnsug

    dark web sites dark market list

  327. Hectorrulky

    deep web drug links dark web search engine

  328. Nickvow
  329. TornItede

    dark market list tor markets links

  330. Drussy

    Meds information sheet. Stimulant Class. is cialis generic tadalafil 5mg price All advice about drug. Assume from here.

  331. BrandenEmago

    darknet sites dark internet

  332. MichaelErolo

    tor markets links deep web drug links

  333. RobertNem

    dark web websites darkmarket list

  334. SirMog

    free dark web darknet drug market

  335. DamonSoasp

    dark web sites links darknet drug store

  336. Haroldeffob

    dark web market list deep dark web

  337. Michaelsenue
  338. Suevow
  339. JasonKit
  340. Curtisgroop
  341. ADWat

    bitcoin dark web darknet markets

  342. JosephMeamn

    darknet seiten dark market url

  343. RandyDed

    dark web link dark web market list

  344. CharlesExips

    tor markets 2022 deep web drug store

  345. Juliustum

    darknet links drug markets onion

  346. Brandoncok

    darkmarket 2022 darknet links

  347. RobertDem

    dark market onion deep web drug store

  348. FrankdiZ

    dark markets dark websites

  349. JackieGuelo

    dark web markets darknet drug store

  350. Williambrido

    deep web drug url bitcoin dark web

  351. Kati hegedum

    you are a person who has taken Microdermabrasion treatment in the past, you should wait 6 months before repeating the treatment.
    Microdermabrasion Treatment in Melbourne

  352. Corrydrent

    dark market onion drug markets dark web

  353. DavidHam

    dark web search engine how to get on dark web

  354. Colbywak
  355. MatthewSmeXy

    dark websites dark web sites

  356. Grantskets

  357. Wendelldualf

  358. RonaldMus

    darknet market links darkmarkets

  359. CharlesTHERN

    deep web drug store darknet search engine

  360. Georgemub

    darkmarket 2022 tor market links

  361. MichaelHow

    darknet drug market darknet seiten

  362. CrisVer

    darknet websites deep web markets

  363. MichaelBiams
  364. Ralphswilk

    deep web links darknet drug links

  365. RichardViorb
  366. GeraldCoola

    dark web access dark web links

  367. Markvow
  368. WilliamCogma

    dark web sites dark market link

  369. PatrickBab

    dark web link deep dark web

  370. DavidZet

    deep web search darkmarket 2022

  371. Michaelamics

    tor markets 2022 dark web websites

  372. Zacharytuh
  373. JamesGlild

    deep web drug links dark market url

  374. Brianmub

    darkmarket list darknet marketplace

  375. EdgarMella
  376. RichardDaync

    dark web market darknet market links

  377. WilliamInamb
  378. JuliannoM

    dark market onion dark web market list

  379. JamesStone

  380. ShanePak

    dark markets deep web sites

  381. Jameserrom

    dark market darknet drugs

  382. Ashvow
  383. JanZex

    darkmarket list dark web search engine

  384. TimmyVAW

    dark web market links deep dark web

  385. DannyEnsug
  386. DonaldAdali

    deep web markets darknet links

  387. Jimvow
  388. Davidves

    darkweb marketplace blackweb

  389. Hectorrulky

    deep web drug markets the dark internet

  390. BrandenEmago

    deep web drug links dark net

  391. Craigpef

    dark web sites bitcoin dark web

  392. RobertNem

    tor marketplace darkmarket list

  393. SirMog

    tor markets 2022 free dark web

  394. Haroldeffob

    darkmarket url darknet links

  395. Williambrido

    the dark internet darkmarket 2022

  396. CharlesExips

    dark web links the dark internet

  397. JasonKit

    blackweb official website darkmarket url

  398. JosephMeamn

    darknet market lists darkmarket url

  399. RandyDed

    darknet sites darknet links

  400. ADWat

    dark web market tor darknet

  401. Juliustum
  402. FrankdiZ
  403. RobertDem

    dark web sites links dark markets

  404. Brandoncok

    darknet drug store free dark web

  405. DamonSoasp

    darknet market lists deep web search

  406. JackieGuelo

    darkweb marketplace darkmarket 2022

  407. Corrydrent
  408. Kimvow
  409. Randyteabe

    bitcoin dark web darkmarket url

  410. Grantskets

  411. DavidHam

    dark web sites free dark web

  412. Boovow
  413. Amyvow
  414. HansGluby

    dark web market list how to access dark web

  415. MatthewSmeXy

    darknet market links darknet drug links

  416. Michaelhetry
  417. Judyvow
  418. CharlesTHERN

    darknet site tor market url

  419. MichaelHow

    deep web drug url dark market 2022

  420. CrisVer

    darknet links dark net

  421. RonaldMus

    tor market url dark web site

  422. Tedvow
  423. RichardViorb

    the dark internet darknet markets

  424. PatrickBab

    bitcoin dark web darkmarket list

  425. best online pharmacy reddit dwaq

    canadian pharmacy coupon kroger pharmacy near me legitimate canadian online pharmacies

  426. WilliamCogma

    dark market onion tor markets links

  427. GeraldCoola

    dark web search engines the dark internet

  428. Michaelamics

    drug markets onion darkmarket

  429. DavidZet

    deep web drug url dark internet

  430. Zacharytuh
  431. EdgarMella

    deep web markets dark websites

  432. JamesGlild

    dark web search engine darknet market

  433. Brianmub

    drug markets dark web darkmarket link

  434. WilliamInamb

    dark market onion tor markets 2022

  435. RichardDaync

    dark market tor markets links

  436. Tedvow
  437. JamesStone

  438. JanZex

    darknet links darknet drug links

  439. MichaelErolo

    deep web sites tor market url

  440. Jameserrom
  441. DonaldAdali

    darknet market list darknet websites

  442. TimmyVAW

    dark market darknet sites

  443. DannyEnsug

    darknet market darkmarkets

  444. ShanePak

    deep web markets dark market

  445. JuliannoM
  446. Miavow
  447. Hectorrulky

    dark web sites links darknet websites

  448. Nickvow
  449. Craigpef

    darknet markets dark market onion

  450. RobertNem

    free dark web tor markets links

  451. Ugovow
  452. EstebanFax
  453. Davidves

    how to access dark web dark market url

  454. Williambrido

    darkmarket list black internet

  455. SirMog

    dark web drug marketplace how to get on dark web

  456. JosephMeamn

    darkmarket list dark market

  457. ADWat
  458. RandyDed

    dark web search engine deep web drug markets

  459. JasonKit

    darknet drug store darknet sites

  460. RobertDem

    darknet search engine dark web market

  461. Juliustum
  462. CharlesExips

    dark web search engines dark web drug marketplace

  463. Haroldeffob
  464. FrankdiZ

    drug markets onion dark web drug marketplace

  465. Brandoncok

    tor dark web deep web search

  466. Hellycalay

    the dark internet onion market

  467. Janevow
  468. JackieGuelo

    darknet sites dark internet

  469. Wendelldualf

  470. Randyteabe

    dark web markets tor markets 2022

  471. HansGluby

    dark market link darknet sites

  472. DamonSoasp

    dark websites darkmarket list

  473. Ashvow
  474. Grantskets

  475. DavidHam

    dark market link tor markets 2022

  476. MatthewSmeXy

    darkmarket link tor dark web

  477. MichaelHow

    dark market 2022 deep web drug store

  478. CharlesTHERN

    dark market list darknet markets

  479. Edwardcor

    https://prescriptiondrugs24.com/# best canadian online pharmacy

  480. CrisVer

    darkmarket 2022 tor darknet

  481. Jasonvow
  482. PatrickBab

    darknet search engine deep web drug url

  483. RichardViorb

    darknet seiten darkmarket 2022

  484. RonaldMus

    darknet search engine deep web markets

  485. BryanRAt

    non prescription ed drugs prescriptiondrugs24.com
    pet antibiotics without vet prescription prescription without seeing doctor

  486. Brianmub
  487. Michaelamics

    deep web drug url dark market list

  488. Zacharytuh

    dark market link deep web drug links

  489. JamesGlild

    dark market onion dark market onion

  490. EdgarMella

    dark web links dark market url

  491. WilliamCogma

    tor market url darkmarket list

  492. MichaelErolo

    darknet drug links dark web drug marketplace

  493. WilliamInamb

    dark web sites links dark web site

  494. RichardDaync
  495. JanZex

    deep web search blackweb

  496. JamesStone

  497. GeraldCoola

    darknet markets dark websites

  498. Jameserrom

    darkweb marketplace deep web search

  499. TimmyVAW

    tor market dark market

  500. Judyvow
  501. DannyEnsug

    deep web drug url dark web sites

  502. DonaldAdali

    dark web markets how to access dark web

  503. ShanePak

    dark market 2022 dark web site

  504. Hectorrulky

    darknet market links tor markets 2022

  505. JuliannoM
  506. Williambrido

    darknet market list darknet market links

  507. RobertNem

    dark web sites drug markets onion

  508. Jimvow
  509. Craigpef

    deep web links dark web markets

  510. SirMog

    how to get on dark web bitcoin dark web

  511. Juliustum

    tor markets 2022 darknet links

  512. Haroldeffob

    dark markets dark web market

  513. JasonKit

    dark internet blackweb

  514. CharlesExips

    dark market link dark web websites

  515. JosephMeamn

    dark market 2022 deep web drug url

  516. RobertDem

    deep web links deep web links

  517. RandyDed

    deep web links deep web markets

  518. ADWat

    dark market tor dark web

  519. Hellycalay

    tor dark web deep web drug url

  520. FrankdiZ
  521. HansGluby

    deep web drug markets darkweb marketplace

  522. Brandoncok

    dark market link dark market

  523. Randyteabe

    dark web search engines deep web links

  524. Wendelldualf

  525. SmittBAM

    dark web search engines dark website

  526. JackieGuelo

    alphabay darknet market alphabay url

  527. DamonSoasp
  528. MatthewSmeXy

    darknet sites tor market

  529. DavidHam

    darkweb marketplace darkmarket

  530. Grantskets

  531. Curtisgroop
  532. MichaelHow

    alphabay link alphabay link

  533. CharlesTHERN

    deep web search dark market link

  534. Mfoormertlu

    cost of pregabalin without rx pregabalin tablet price where buy generic pregabalin no prescription

  535. CrisVer

    darknet drug store darknet market lists

  536. Janevow
  537. SteveWax

    alphabay market alphabay market darknet

  538. PatrickBab

    dark web search engines darknet market lists

  539. Wimvow
  540. RichardViorb

    alphabay url alphabay market

  541. Michaelamics

    darknet drug links darknet drug market

  542. Zacharytuh

    darknet market darknet links

  543. DavidZet
  544. Brianmub

    dark market deep web links

  545. Nickvow
  546. JamesGlild

    dark markets free dark web

  547. EdgarMella
  548. Zakvow
  549. JanZex
  550. RonaldMus

    onion market tor dark web

  551. WilliamCogma

    dark market list darknet links

  552. WilliamInamb

    deep web search how to access dark web

  553. RichardDaync
  554. Ashvow
  555. JamesStone

  556. DannyEnsug

    dark website dark web access

  557. DonaldAdali

    deep web drug store darkmarket link

  558. TimmyVAW

    darkmarkets tor marketplace

  559. Jameserrom

    dark web search engines dark market link

  560. GeraldCoola

    dark web market tor market

  561. Williambrido

    blackweb official website how to access dark web

  562. MarvinTam
  563. Judyvow
  564. Hectorrulky

    alphabay darknet market alphabay url

  565. Wimvow
  566. ShanePak

    tor markets 2022 deep web markets

  567. RobertNem

    deep dark web bitcoin dark web

  568. JuliannoM
  569. JosephMeamn

    tor darknet tor dark web

  570. SirMog

    bitcoin dark web dark web search engine

  571. CharlesExips
  572. ADWat
  573. RandyDed

    tor marketplace tor darknet

  574. JasonKit

    deep web drug links dark web drug marketplace

  575. Haroldeffob

    tor markets darkmarket url

  576. Juliustum

    onion market darkmarket url

  577. RobertDem
  578. EstebanFax
  579. Robertdit
  580. Hellycalay

    tor dark web dark net

  581. Miavow
  582. Ralphswilk

    deep web search darknet drug store

  583. Georgemub

    darknet seiten deep web links

  584. Craigpef

    darknet marketplace dark web sites

  585. FrankdiZ

    darknet marketplace darkmarkets

  586. Brandoncok

    darknet search engine dark internet

  587. Zakvow
  588. Wendelldualf

  589. SmittBAM

    dark web market list darknet market links

  590. JackieGuelo

    alphabay market link alphabay darknet market

  591. Teovow
  592. MatthewSmeXy

    deep web drug url dark website

  593. DavidHam

    dark websites dark markets 2022

  594. Grantskets

  595. Wimvow
  596. CrisVer

    darkweb marketplace darknet drug links

  597. MichaelHow

    alphabay link alphabay market url

  598. BrandenEmago

    alphabay market alphabay market darknet

  599. CharlesTHERN

    deep web sites darkmarket

  600. DamonSoasp
  601. Jackvow
  602. Mfoormertog

    pregabalin tablet price can i order cheap pregabalin without a prescription can i purchase pregabalin for sale

  603. PatrickBab

    how to access dark web drug markets dark web

  604. Curtisgroop
  605. JanZex

    darkmarkets tor markets links

  606. TornItede

    dark website dark market list

  607. Michaelamics

    dark market url dark markets 2022

  608. WilliamCogma

    dark markets tor marketplace

  609. Zacharytuh

    bitcoin dark web darknet market lists

  610. Brianmub

    tor market url dark net

  611. RichardViorb

    alphabay market darknet alphabay market url

  612. DavidZet

    tor market url darknet drug store

  613. Amyvow
  614. JamesGlild

    tor markets links blackweb official website

  615. EdgarMella

    alphabay market url alphabay darknet market

  616. WilliamInamb

    deep web sites blackweb

  617. RichardDaync
  618. RonaldMus

    drug markets dark web dark web sites

  619. JamesStone

  620. DanielCet
  621. DonaldAdali

    how to get on dark web deep web markets

  622. DannyEnsug

    drug markets onion dark web site

  623. TimmyVAW
  624. Jameserrom

    dark web sites deep web links

  625. GeraldCoola

    darknet market list darkmarket link

  626. ADWat

    blackweb official website darkmarket url

  627. Hectorrulky

    alphabay url alphabay url

  628. RobertNem

    deep dark web best darknet markets

  629. JosephMeamn

    darknet drug store dark web markets

  630. ShanePak

    dark websites darkmarket

  631. HansGluby

    darknet market darknet drug market

  632. JasonKit

    dark web market links dark web drug marketplace

  633. Juliustum

    dark market 2022 darknet site

  634. CharlesExips

    dark website darknet drug store

  635. SirMog

    drug markets onion darknet sites

  636. RandyDed

    darknet market dark markets 2022

  637. Haroldeffob

    darknet market darknet search engine

  638. Teovow
  639. RobertDem

    alphabay market darknet alphabay url

  640. JuliannoM

    dark markets tor market url

  641. DavisNen
  642. FrankdiZ

    bitcoin dark web deep dark web

  643. Lisavow
  644. Brandoncok

    drug markets onion how to access dark web

  645. Craigpef

    drug markets dark web dark net

  646. Antwan

    I am actually glad to read this webpage posts which includes tons of useful
    data, thanks for providing these kinds of data.

  647. Wendelldualf

  648. SmittBAM

    deep web drug markets tor markets 2022

  649. Miavow
  650. JackieGuelo

    alphabay market link alphabay market

  651. BrandenEmago

    alphabay link alphabay market url

  652. DavidHam

    dark web search engine dark web market list

  653. MatthewSmeXy

    tor market url dark web links

  654. Grantskets

  655. CrisVer

    dark web access deep web links

  656. CharlesTHERN

    dark market link tor darknet

  657. WilliamCogma

    dark markets deep web search

  658. MichaelHow

    alphabay link alphabay url

  659. JanZex

    darkmarket free dark web

  660. PatrickBab

    darkmarket list darknet seiten

  661. Janevow
  662. DamonSoasp

    tor markets links tor marketplace

  663. DavidZet

    dark market url darknet market links

  664. Michaelamics

    dark web sites links darkmarket link

  665. Zacharytuh

    dark web market list darknet market lists

  666. Timothygor
  667. RichardViorb

    alphabay market url alphabay market link

  668. Brianmub

    darknet drug store dark web search engine

  669. JamesGlild

    darknet sites bitcoin dark web

  670. JustinBum

    dark website dark market url

  671. DanielCet

    dark web site blackweb

  672. EdgarMella

    alphabay market alphabay link

  673. WilliamInamb

    darknet links darknet markets

  674. RichardDaync

    dark market url darknet drugs

  675. JamesStone

  676. RonaldMus
  677. DonaldAdali

    how to get on dark web dark web links

  678. DannyEnsug

    dark web search engines blackweb

  679. TimmyVAW

    tor darknet dark website

  680. Jameserrom
  681. Hellycalay

    tor marketplace free dark web

  682. JosephMeamn

    tor markets links darkmarket url

  683. Lisavow
  684. HansGluby

    dark web market links dark web access

  685. GeraldCoola

    dark web market list dark web search engines

  686. CharlesExips

    darkweb marketplace darknet drug links

  687. RobertNem

    dark internet tor dark web

  688. Hectorrulky

    alphabay market url alphabay darknet market

  689. RandyDed

    bitcoin dark web darknet drug store

  690. SirMog

    deep web drug links dark market link

  691. JasonKit

    darknet market tor market links

  692. Juliustum

    darknet drugs darkmarket url

  693. Haroldeffob

    best darknet markets darknet markets

  694. ShanePak

    how to get on dark web dark websites

  695. RobertDem

    alphabay market darknet alphabay market

  696. Rodneymax
  697. CharlesGag
  698. FrankdiZ
  699. JuliannoM

    dark web search engine darkmarket url

  700. Brandoncok

    deep dark web dark markets 2022

  701. MichaelErolo
  702. Wendelldualf

  703. SmittBAM
  704. Craigpef

    dark web websites dark web websites

  705. Rodneymax
  706. tadalafil cost walmart bvpl

    And erectile dysfunction is unacceptable to transmute into without some treatment or lifestyle changes. Your mute finally should see his health take charge of provider about erectile dysfunction. Erectile dysfunction is the unqualifiedness to work out or mind an erection business sufficiently in search sex. It’s a common problem. Source: cialis coupon cvs

  707. JackieGuelo

    alphabay market darknet alphabay market url

  708. WilliamCogma

    dark web market deep dark web

  709. DavidHam

    dark markets dark web market

  710. MatthewSmeXy

    deep web sites dark web sites links

  711. CrisVer
  712. JanZex

    darknet links darknet market links

  713. Grantskets

  714. CharlesTHERN

    darknet markets dark web search engine

  715. MichaelHow
  716. SamuelPaish
  717. Williambrido

    tor markets links onion market

  718. Michaelamics

    dark web links dark web links

  719. Zacharytuh

    darknet market lists blackweb official website

  720. PatrickBab

    tor darknet dark web market

  721. DavidZet

    deep dark web tor marketplace

  722. RichardViorb

    alphabay market link alphabay market url

  723. Brianmub

    dark market list how to access dark web

  724. JamesGlild

    deep web drug links darknet market list

  725. DamonSoasp

    deep web markets dark web links

  726. WilliamInamb

    tor marketplace darknet markets

  727. RichardDaync

    dark market link deep web drug url

  728. EdgarMella

    alphabay darknet market alphabay market url

  729. JamesStone

  730. DonaldAdali

    dark web link dark web market

  731. TimmyVAW

    darkweb marketplace darknet market links

  732. DannyEnsug

    darknet drug market best darknet markets

  733. ADWat

    deep dark web darknet market

  734. Randyteabe
  735. RonaldMus

    deep web drug markets deep dark web

  736. Jameserrom

    the dark internet tor marketplace

  737. JanZex

    darknet market darknet site

  738. Ralphswilk

    dark web sites deep web search

  739. Yonvow
  740. RandyDed

    darknet seiten dark website

  741. JasonKit

    dark web links dark market 2022

  742. Juliustum

    darknet market list darkmarket link

  743. CharlesExips

    dark web drug marketplace dark web markets

  744. RobertNem
  745. SirMog

    dark markets dark internet

  746. Hectorrulky

    alphabay darknet market alphabay market

  747. GeraldCoola

    darknet market links dark web links

  748. Haroldeffob

    deep web search dark web links

  749. Hellycalay

    darknet seiten dark web market

  750. RobertDem

    alphabay market link alphabay market link

  751. SteveWax

    alphabay darknet market alphabay link

  752. ShanePak

    darkmarket link the dark internet

  753. FrankdiZ

    dark website dark market

  754. Brandoncok

    dark markets 2022 dark web websites

  755. Michaelhetry
  756. Wendelldualf

  757. SmittBAM
  758. WilliamCogma

    tor dark web dark web sites

  759. JuliannoM

    darkmarket 2022 dark net

  760. Craigpef

    drug markets onion darknet marketplace

  761. CrisVer

    dark markets tor markets links

  762. JackieGuelo

    alphabay market darknet alphabay link

  763. DavidHam

    tor market free dark web

  764. MatthewSmeXy

    dark web markets dark web access

  765. DanielCet

    bitcoin dark web darknet drugs

  766. Grantskets

  767. CharlesTHERN

    dark web sites links darkmarket link

  768. Michaelamics

    deep web drug store dark market

  769. Zacharytuh

    dark web site darknet market links

  770. PatrickBab

    darkmarkets dark web access

  771. MichaelHow

    alphabay market link alphabay market link

  772. Timothygor
  773. DavidZet

    dark markets deep dark web

  774. Janevow
  775. Michaelpycle
  776. RichardViorb

    alphabay market alphabay darknet market

  777. Amyvow
  778. JamesGlild

    deep web search how to get on dark web

  779. Denvow
  780. RichardDaync

    darknet market lists dark web sites

  781. WilliamInamb

    free dark web dark web websites

  782. Georgemub

    dark market dark web websites

  783. Randyteabe

    dark market 2022 darknet market links

  784. Corrydrent

    dark web site tor markets 2022

  785. ADWat

    darknet drug links deep web search

  786. JamesStone

  787. EdgarMella

    alphabay market alphabay link

  788. DamonSoasp

    darkmarket darkmarket url

  789. DonaldAdali

    dark web websites deep web search

  790. DannyEnsug

    darknet market links deep web drug url

  791. TimmyVAW

    darkweb marketplace dark web link

  792. HansGluby

    dark web market links darkmarket url

  793. Lisavow
  794. Jameserrom
  795. JanZex
  796. MiclInork
  797. RonaldMus

    dark market 2022 dark web sites links

  798. Juliustum

    onion market dark market 2022

  799. Hectorrulky

    alphabay market alphabay market url

  800. RandyDed

    best darknet markets deep web drug links

  801. JasonKit

    how to get on dark web onion market

  802. CharlesExips

    the dark internet dark web access

  803. SirMog

    dark market onion deep web drug links

  804. RobertNem

    darknet search engine deep web drug url

  805. MichaelErolo

    alphabay market url alphabay market darknet

  806. Haroldeffob

    darknet websites dark web market links

  807. Hellycalay

    dark web market list best darknet markets

  808. RobertDem

    alphabay darknet market alphabay market url

  809. GeraldCoola

    tor marketplace dark web market list

  810. WilliamCogma

    darknet drug store tor markets

  811. Miavow
  812. FrankdiZ

    deep web links dark web sites

  813. ShanePak

    dark web search engine deep web drug store

  814. Brandoncok
  815. Wendelldualf

  816. SmittBAM

    deep web sites free dark web

  817. TornItede

    deep web drug links deep web markets

  818. Williambrido
  819. Ashvow
  820. ElwoodSpara
  821. JuliannoM

    darknet market deep web links

  822. JackieGuelo

    alphabay darknet market alphabay market url

  823. DavidHam
  824. MatthewSmeXy
  825. Craigpef

    bitcoin dark web dark web access

  826. Grantskets

  827. Michaelamics

    darkmarket darkmarket link

  828. PatrickBab

    darknet market links dark market url